14 Comments
User's avatar
B1234's avatar

https://vdare.com/articles/how-the-death-penalty-saved-civilization

In this article the authors hypothesize that Caucasian Christian Europe's death penalty from the 1400s to the 1800s got rid of the low IQ , low impulse control, and sociopathic groups. Perhaps in the time since then whites are beginning to "regress to the mean" and the resulting low IQ low impulse control whites end up in prison while the sociopaths end up in Government or the Corporate world.

Blacks and Hispanics didn't have the same culture, so it is the average that ends up in prison.

Expand full comment
Enon's avatar

Sampling issues? Maybe the test was optional and the dumb prisoners disn't take it. Maybe the specific prisons tested were ones that were low-security ones or more desirable ones and the lower IQ prisoners had been effectively screened out.

Expand full comment
Daniel's avatar

Not just IQ though.I remember watching a video by Jared Taylor on the topic of psychopathics and I think it was about Eric dutlin's book.How different races have different levels of psychopathic tendencies

Expand full comment
Alden Whitfeld's avatar

I think you’re referring to “Race Differences in Psychopathic Personality” which is by the now deceased Richard Lynn.

Expand full comment
Daniel's avatar

The book is by Edward Dutton.I forgot his title though, but I have a question.Would you ever do an article on his book?The past of a future country where he goes into depth about the inevitable collapse of the liberal intelligency, how they're getting dumber, we're conservative are getting smarter

Expand full comment
Alden Whitfeld's avatar

I’m not exactly sure what you want me to cover from his book. I’ve read it in its entirety already. It’s debatable if differential fertility would actually save the West.

Expand full comment
Daniel's avatar

While liberal intellectualism is doomed either way, either it gets replaced by Islam or conservatives and recandles itself.It takes over

Expand full comment
Daniel's avatar

Two novels that explore both outcomes the day of the rope and submission

Expand full comment
Daniel Povey's avatar

Perhaps the crime IQ correlation was only true due to between race differences in the first place.

Expand full comment
Zero Contradictions's avatar

Out of curiosity, what prompts were used regarding the IQ test in the image?

Expand full comment
Alden Whitfeld's avatar

I think it was just “prisoner taking an IQ test”, after which I tried repeatedly to get the AI to flip the test to have the correct orientation.

Expand full comment
David's avatar

There are too many confounding variables in the prison dataset. The proper way to do this type of study is to first separate the prisoners into people who committed violent crimes vs non-violent crimes. White collar criminals like Bernie Madoff probably has an ABOVE AVERAE IQ. I wouldn't be surprised if Bernie's IQ is at least 120.

I would like to see a study focusing only on prisons who committed violence on other people. Take out all the white-collar, drug dealers, and drunk drivers, etc.

Expand full comment
Alden Whitfeld's avatar

Unfortunately, it is not possible to separate the prisoners into violent vs. nonviolent in the datasets used.

Also, if that’s the confounding variable, and we assume that violent criminals are the “low IQ prisoners” within each race, this would have to imply that white prisoners are disproportionately comprised of violent offenders compared to blacks and Hispanics in order to explain why the IQ differential between the incarcerated and non-incarcerated population is almost entirely on whites only. This doesn’t seem to be very likely.

Expand full comment
David's avatar

Doing good science is hard, that's why these studies are flawed. How do we know that the prisoner samples are randomly selected? Were the surveys taken from minimum security prisons or maximum security prisons? If the researchers didn't bother coding the prisoner's sentence term and offense during intake for later analysis, they're doing bad science.

Haven't you read about the replication crisis? Studies don't replicate because they're bad.

Expand full comment